Yesterday's Apagón

Everyone living in mainland Chile between Arica and Puerto Montt was affected by yesterday’s major electrical blackout.
It was due to simultaneous failures in both sections of a double transmission line in the Norte Chico, which at the time was feeding 2GW southwards. Its probably no coincidence that this event occurred at a period of peak demand in Santiago, (3 pm on a hot summer workday.)

The remaining generators online at the time didn’t have the capacity to compensate for this abrupt loss of power, and automatically shut themselves down in cascade to prevent overloading and damage.

Re-establishing power takes time as each generating station has go through a startup process before reconnection, first locally, then carefully synchronized with the national grid. This process can’t be rushed, and can take several hours, especially where grid interruption may have caused secondary failures.

As is usual here, communications was the first casualty due to the limited standby battery capacity of most Cellular base stations. Here in the Coquimbo region, most FM radio stations also went off-air, one notable exception being Radio BioBio’s local transmission.

We took some basic precautions such as storing water and dropping our main circuit breakers to avoid equipment damage if power isn’t cleanly restored.

This morning we woke to find that our power was back on, as seems to be the case in most of the country.

1 Like

Thanks for the summary of the cause. Yeah our power came back on a bit before 10pm here in Araucania.

Would be interested to know how Starlink internet users fared, assuming that their equipment was on battery backup, that is :roll_eyes:

1 Like

Ours came back after 11 p.m. We completely lost cellular/data service. I do have a battery-powered radio for situations like this and there were a few stations on air. That’s how we knew it was widespread. In summer the power sometimes goes out when it’s hot and everyone has their AC on. So, at first we thought that might be what was going on.

Do they know what caused those failures in the double transmission line in Norte Chico?

For a while I still had cellular/data service after the power went out. Maybe two hours. Then no bars on Virgin or Entel.

Just checking in, yesterday and today, to see how the power cut has evolved. The reporting seems to indicate a double transmission fault, which is definitely unusual and will need some explanation. Here in Argentina we had our last major power cut on Fathers’ Day in 2019, when Argentina (except Tierra del Fuego), Paraguay, Uruguay, and parts of Brazil and I believe also Chile lost power due to a fault at the Yacyretá dam (plus other parts of the grid being offline for maintenance, like the Atocha nuclear power plan down the road).

About mobile phone service, the battery backup for the base stations should last for more than 1-2 hours, more like 24 or 48 hours depending on the operator and how they equipped their base stations. Certainly in Valdivia, mobile service lasted 8-9 hours, it was a bit slow, but it worked. It probably depends on the operator, Entel have money to burn, Claro has a reputation for being cheap, and Movistar wants to leave.

According to the national electricity coordinator, this should never have happened. I would suspect it was due to what we used to call “finger trouble”, aka operator error, since there are no reports of equipment damage in the lines or at the substations.
The truth may emerge after the formal investigation concludes, in 15 days or so.

Elephant in the room…possibly intentional, maybe a stern warning from the same outside forces that helped the CCP with their “El Estallido Delictual” octobre 2019 and onwards, or even more conspiratorial, with the cooperation of the CCP as an experimental psyop on the pueblo chileno.

1 Like

Of course an apagón is the most certain way for Chile to show its farcical Turd World faces.

The count: 3 dead, but apparently they were dependent upon life support systems that lacked UPS. The government is disputing that their deaths were the result of the apagón.

207 arrests due to curfew violations.

The government is now reporting that two “private companies” were to blame for the outage.

Ministress of the Interior, Carolina Tohá, reported that electricity service was restored in 90% of the country although there are still cities without electricity in some cities of the Norte Grande -Arica and Antofagasta- due to the theft of some electrical conductors during the night, as well as in some areas of greater Santiago and the Valparaíso region

Solidarity: it’s what makes Chile what it is.


Boric himself publicly insisted that the outage was “due to a failure of the company called ISA InterChile, in the transmission line that goes between Vallenar and Coquimbo…”…

That company is the Chilean subsidiary of the Colombian group ISA, in charge of the Cardones - Polpaico, Encuentro Lagunas and Kimal - Lo Aguirre transmission line, which "should have been disconnected due to “an undesirable operation” (phrase used by the president of the national electric coordination agency, Juan Carlos Olmedo).

A spokesperson from ISA InterChile explained that the fault was in a so-called double circuit in the Nueva Maitencillo – Nueva Pan de Azúcar segment that operates at 500,000 volts, between Vallenar and Coquimbo. At the time of the fault it was reportedly transmitting a total energy level of about 1,800 MW. That company insisted that it cured its part of the fault in 44 minutes.

Lots of finger pointing.

Chile’s Energy minister said that what caused the problem for most of the country was the delay in reestablishing service, pointing to another company - Transelec - as being jointly responsible for one of the failures that delayed the restoration of service.

Keystone chispas…

The minister said that the long period of the outage had to do with “a set of responsibilities that also have to do with other companies and other institutions related to the coordination of the electrical system.”


Edit: Since Aysén and Magallanes are not connected to the SIC (now called the SEN, the Sistema Eléctrico Nacional), we were unaware of the apagón until it eventually made the news. The SEN concept, and the resulting apagón, should be viewed as a reminder of the hazards of the country’s mania for centralism with fractured system management. And Chile’s enemies are now aware of how to bring the entire fooking country to its knees. Cada inepto con su tema.

The independent grids in Aysén

As Bradanovic (Tombrad) wrote a few years ago in a warning about this interconnectivity:

1 Like

The model of power networking used in Chile and elsewhere, where energy is generated in locations a long way from its eventual destination makes for a fragile system unless some redundancy is built in. But putting additional power sources online costs money, so I guess that the system is engineered to minimize costs,(or maximize profits) rather than prioritize reliability. Chile has (or had) enough installed capacity even before the SING-SIC interconnector was installed. But when it failed, there was no spare generating capacity online in the system at the time to take up the load.

Faced with this situation, other countries such as South Africa use “load shedding” to selectively cut power on a sectorial basis rather than letting the whole grid go down as happened here.

But whatever measures are adopted to improve grid integrity, you can bet the result will be increased consumer electricity prices.

Edit: Basket-case South Africa is not a good example to emulate as it only adopted “load shedding” as a result of gross mismanagement in the energy sector. But we may see similar measures employed in more advanced nations such as the UK and Germany with their deluded adoption of intermittent “renewable” energy sources.

The following link includes an in-depth video that offers a detailed exposition of electrical power realities.

1 Like

Two related discussion threads that gave me a more insight.

and

This was a “dry run” in my opinion, I can’t even imagine a combination of earthquake, fires, floods.

1 Like

We already suffered this not that long ago, in 2010. Mosciatti’s recent video reminds us of this, and other Chilean vulnerabilities.

At that time, the Ruta5 was impassible, and the only communications to the South of Chile was via Military and Ham HF radio. The US donated some Iridium sat phones to help out.

Later on, I sent a letter to El Mercurio, which they published, where I proposed setting up a national emergency communications system using (already-existing) geostationary satellites to establish bases in all the regional capitals for the exclusive use of the local authorities in order to coordinate their response to emergency situations, both back to the capital, and also with inter-regional capability.

But like most emergencies here, after the fuss died down, nothing was ever done. These days, with the advent of the higher-bandwidth, lower-latency Starlink system, this would be even easier and cheaper to set up. and could even incorporate NPR-type radio transmitters to keep the local populations informed, in the absence of commercial radio and cell services.

It would have cost a tiny fraction of the USD $700M or more that Chile is spending on the Puente Chacao, but it’s not so attractive from a political point of view, compared to a big impressive bridge…one of Piñera’s “legacy” projects.

Well 2010 some might argue was a long time ago at 15 years, but agreed its not like 25 years.

Likely most of the people that evaluated doing something like establishing regional bases for immediate communication arent even still in the same jobs. Probably replaced by millienials or genz’rs.

All of this has happened before and all of it will happen again…just with differnt warm bodies choosing the same paths of least resistance in general.

1 Like

Boric and the apagón.

An initial quick survey of the US-based news media with Spanish editions (“Bloomberg” and so on) pushed the message that the apagón events did not adversely affect the merluzo’s public approval.

Then onto Chilean media, starting with this

and then

I find it mildly amusing that Boric approval is noted as 29 percent in Chile and Trump approval within the US at around 44 percent.

Anyway, the handling of the apagón didn’t offer any opportunities for Boric to look any better, and by association, there are likely losses in confidence for his coalition.

It is truly amazing the new levels of fail that Boric has achieved. Good grief has there ever been such a polarized fall from grace?

People were crying tears of joy in the street when he was elected. Now less than 1 in 3 even basically approve of him.

A cautionary tale if there ever was one.

Fun, fun, we lost power yesterday again. It was localized. One of my emergency lights broke, it’s had so much work lately. I ordered a few more.

https://www.radioagricultura.cl/noticias/nacional/corte-de-luz-afecta-a-la-comuna-de-buin-hay-casi-9-mil-clientes-sin-suministro-electrico_20250303/

CGE

Lost power yesterday too, 16:00 – 20:00 (Coquimbo centro).

A funny thing: the SEC gas inspectors recently forced my landlord to install a “tiro forzadocalefont to assign a “green” status to the apartment, that is obviously NOT working during power failures (while the old one that used batteries worked just fine)… very wise. Let’s go green.

1 Like

Sorry you had another problem too. Our calefont is battery-powered. My husband complains about having to change the batteries. I guess I would tell him at least it works when the power goes out :joy: !

Well, since I stuck my nose back into the forum, I might as well comment on this topic.

I think expectations of functioning communications after an 8+ earthquake are a bit unrealistic. When your whole country is moved a few metres to the east and all your geostationary antennas are left pointing at, well, outer space, there’s not much you can do. Plus your fibre optic connections (now the rule in telecoms) will probably have been cut at some point. And the shaking around won’t have done any remaining microwave backhaul connections any good either.

When I was working with Entel in 2014, I understand there was a plan to establish a government mobile network for emergencies, with no single point of failure, etc, to be initially run by Entel. I don’t find any references online, and maybe it never happened, but even if it did, it’s just a gamble really.

And parts of Chile get cut off from the world anyway, even without earthquakes (Punta Arenas, Isla de Pascua) and even with satellite comms (their only option, really).

Starlink is out of capacity already in the south of Argentina, probably also in Chile, and can be turned off on a whim anyway. Not a solution for emergencies.

Seriously, it’s a bit complicated. There isn’t always someone to blame.

+1 for initiative, -10 for realism to the El Mercurio correspondent?